Posts Tagged ‘violation’

TERA Got Sued by NCsoft in the U.S.

January 26th, 2012

TERA at E3 2011

NCsoft and its North American corporation NC Interactive have submitted a case to a southern district court in New York province, the U.S.  for a prohibition of launching <TERA> in the U.S. as well as return of confidential information and a compensation claim on the 9th of January; the defendants of the case are Bluehole Studio and En Mass Entertainment, respectively the developer and the North American publisher of MMORPG <TERA>.

NCsoft has asserted that Bluehole Studio has violated the copyright on MMORPG <Lineage 3> which used to be ceased for a while as Bluehole Studio leaked core technology of it, also stating violation of business secrets, violation of Non Disclosure Agreement(NDA), unfair competition, and other reasons.

To help you understand this situation, NCsoft and Bluehole’s ill-fated relationship has developed since last 2007.

In 2007, NCsoft requested a police investigation over Bluehole for leakage of the business secrets of <Lineage 3> in Korea. In August 2008, it sued Bluehole for that <TERA> derived from its then next generation MMORPG and claimed US$5.8M for damage. In December of the same year, the prosecution charged five ex-<Lineage 3> developers for the leaked secrets.

In 2010, the Korean court ruled that the defendant’s firm is not guilty but the five are guilty.

But <TERA> in the U.S. has not even launched yet. Then why would NCsoft sue them there, not in Japan where the commercial service already started off? And why now?

Most of the industry officials deem that NCsoft is trying to interrupt the NA server which is scheduled to be open on May 1. Moreover, it’s drawing the industry’s attention as the lawsuit is taking place while a controversy over protecting copyrights, SOPA and PIPA for examples, is going on in the U.S. today.

Both companies are unforthcoming about the situation. “We are looking for a law firm in NA and will announce our official stance as soon as we find one,” said a Bluehole official. “Take this lawsuit as prolongation of the lawsuit in Korea,” said a NCsoft official.

Share on TwitterSubmit to redditDigg ThisShare on Tumblr

Starcraft eSports on Settlement Track

May 11th, 2011

The conflict derived from <Starcraft> eSports is now on settlement track. Blizzard, MBC Games, OnGameNet, and KeSPA are meeting to solve the conflict peacefully. To that end, the 4th hearing scheduled on May 13 is postponed to next month.

The negotiation would be end as early as May and the lawsuit would be naturally withdrawn if Blizzard shakes hands with MBC Games and OnGameNet over the IP violation.

This settlement is limited to only <Starcraft>. Reportedly, Korean eSports would admit the IP of <Starcraft> and Blizzard would accept most of demands of the industry.

An official said “There has been no winner since the conflict began. The broadcasters had hard time on attracting sponsors for the leagues and Blizzard had negative marketing effect when <Starcraft 2> launched. So I guess they both had some common need on settlement.”

Share on TwitterSubmit to redditDigg ThisShare on Tumblr